• About Us
  • Our Contributors
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
Wednesday, May 14, 2025
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
FactFile
  • National
  • International
  • Economy
  • Health
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Tech
    Pakistan, ICMPD Launch FJA-PAK to Combat Online Job Scams and Human Trafficking

    Pakistan, ICMPD Launch FJA-PAK to Combat Online Job Scams and Human Trafficking

    ‘X Unbanned in Pakistan’ After Cowardly Strikes by India

    ‘X Unbanned in Pakistan’ After Cowardly Strikes by India

    When will Starlink Internet Services Launch in Pakistan?

    When will Starlink Internet Services Launch in Pakistan?

    iPhone Price in Pakistan May Hit Rs1 Million Amid Tariffs

    iPhone Price in Pakistan May Hit Rs1 Million Amid Tariffs

    Google Launches Gemini 2.5 Pro

    Google Launches Gemini 2.5 Pro

    Huawei Partners with SIFC to Train 300, 000 Pakistanis in IT Skills

    Huawei Partners with SIFC to Train 300, 000 Pakistanis in IT Skills

  • Entertainment
    Sushmita Sen Backs Return of Pakistani Artists to Bollywood

    Sushmita Sen Backs Return of Pakistani Artists to Bollywood

    Hania Amir Wows with Dance at Maria Unera’s Wedding

    Hania Amir Wows with Dance at Maria Unera’s Wedding

    Aishwarya Rai Bachchan’s Car Involved in Accident, Video Goes Viral

    Aishwarya Rai Bachchan’s Car Involved in Accident, Video Goes Viral

    Violence Breaks Out at Sonu Nigam’s Live Concert in Delhi

    Violence Breaks Out at Sonu Nigam’s Live Concert in Delhi

    Actress Mandana Karimi bids farewell to Bollywood, Here’s why!

    Actress Mandana Karimi bids farewell to Bollywood, Here’s why!

    From romantic ballads to upbeat hits: Discover the top trending Pakistani Music of 2024

    From romantic ballads to upbeat hits: Discover the top trending Pakistani Music of 2024

    Talha Anjum named Most-Streamed Artist of 2024 on Spotify

    Talha Anjum named Most-Streamed Artist of 2024 on Spotify

    Iain Armitage named world's richest child actor with $6 million net worth

    Iain Armitage named world’s richest child actor with $6 million net worth

    Javed Sheikh makes a surprising revelation about his iconic on-screen look

    Javed Sheikh makes a surprising revelation about his iconic on-screen look

  • Opinion
  • National
  • International
  • Economy
  • Health
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Tech
    Pakistan, ICMPD Launch FJA-PAK to Combat Online Job Scams and Human Trafficking

    Pakistan, ICMPD Launch FJA-PAK to Combat Online Job Scams and Human Trafficking

    ‘X Unbanned in Pakistan’ After Cowardly Strikes by India

    ‘X Unbanned in Pakistan’ After Cowardly Strikes by India

    When will Starlink Internet Services Launch in Pakistan?

    When will Starlink Internet Services Launch in Pakistan?

    iPhone Price in Pakistan May Hit Rs1 Million Amid Tariffs

    iPhone Price in Pakistan May Hit Rs1 Million Amid Tariffs

    Google Launches Gemini 2.5 Pro

    Google Launches Gemini 2.5 Pro

    Huawei Partners with SIFC to Train 300, 000 Pakistanis in IT Skills

    Huawei Partners with SIFC to Train 300, 000 Pakistanis in IT Skills

  • Entertainment
    Sushmita Sen Backs Return of Pakistani Artists to Bollywood

    Sushmita Sen Backs Return of Pakistani Artists to Bollywood

    Hania Amir Wows with Dance at Maria Unera’s Wedding

    Hania Amir Wows with Dance at Maria Unera’s Wedding

    Aishwarya Rai Bachchan’s Car Involved in Accident, Video Goes Viral

    Aishwarya Rai Bachchan’s Car Involved in Accident, Video Goes Viral

    Violence Breaks Out at Sonu Nigam’s Live Concert in Delhi

    Violence Breaks Out at Sonu Nigam’s Live Concert in Delhi

    Actress Mandana Karimi bids farewell to Bollywood, Here’s why!

    Actress Mandana Karimi bids farewell to Bollywood, Here’s why!

    From romantic ballads to upbeat hits: Discover the top trending Pakistani Music of 2024

    From romantic ballads to upbeat hits: Discover the top trending Pakistani Music of 2024

    Talha Anjum named Most-Streamed Artist of 2024 on Spotify

    Talha Anjum named Most-Streamed Artist of 2024 on Spotify

    Iain Armitage named world's richest child actor with $6 million net worth

    Iain Armitage named world’s richest child actor with $6 million net worth

    Javed Sheikh makes a surprising revelation about his iconic on-screen look

    Javed Sheikh makes a surprising revelation about his iconic on-screen look

  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
FactFile
No Result
View All Result
CJP to announce decision on CM Punjab election case at 5:45pm

CJP to announce decision on CM Punjab election case at 5:45pm

by Arshad Khan
July 26, 2022
in National
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedIn Whatsapp

Parliamentary party gives directions for voting: CJP

CJP to announce decision on CM Punjab election case at 5:45pm. Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) said Tuesday that the Supreme Court will announce the verdict in the Punjab chief minister’s election case — where Hamza Shahbaz defeated Pervez Elahi — at 5:45pm today (Tuesday).

The proceedings went on for three days — Saturday, Monday, and Tuesday — as lawyers from all the parties presented their arguments.

Elahi, who had been defeated on July 22 after 10 PML-Q votes were rejected by Deputy Speaker Punjab Assembly Dost Mazari, had challenged the ruling in the SC.

The SC formed a three-member bench — headed by Chief Justice Umar Ata Bandial and including Justice Munib Akhtar and Justice Ijazul Ahsan — to hear the case, but the coalition government objected to it and demanded a full court take up the matter as they did not want “bench-fixing”.

More From FactFile: SC rejects govt’s request for full court bench

However, after hearing arguments from all sides for nearly eight hours on Monday, the SC decided not to form a full court bench, saying that the same bench would hear the case.

As the SC decided not to form a full bench, the ruling coalition and the Pakistan Democratic Movement (PDM) decided to boycott the apex court’s hearing.

Today’s hearing

Qadir told the bench that his client had told him to not be a part of the proceedings as a country-wide boycott of the judiciary is being observed.

Qadir told the SC that he would challenge the apex court’s decision relating to the full court — wherein the top court decided to not form a full bench to hear the case.

Following Qadir, PPP lawyer Farooq H Naek came to the rostrum and informed the CJP that he would not be part of the proceedings.

At this, the CJP told him that he “is not a party in the case”.

The CJP said that “no legal” grounds were presented before the court; arguments were presented only regarding the party head’s directions; the court arrived at the conclusion that in the current case, there was no need for a full bench.

 “I will change my opinion only when concrete reasons are given.”

CJP Bandial said the real question was who could give directions to party lawmakers. The constitution clearly states that the parliamentary party will give directions to MPs, he said.

“There is no need for further arguments in this case. We will give priority to wrapping up this case as soon as possible,” he said.

CJP Bandial said that forming a full court was tantamount to unnecessary delay.

“The formation of a full court and then hearing of the case could have been delayed till September as leaves are being taken in the court.”

Meanwhile, the top court sought assistance on the matter relating to directions by the party head or a parliamentary party.

 “Assist the court over the legal questions or we will set ourselves aside from the bench,” CJP Bandial told Barrister Ali Zafar, the counsel of Elahi.

 “People sitting on my right side have unanimously decided to boycott the proceedings of the court,” he said, adding that thankfully, they have enough grace to sit in court to hear the proceedings.

Giving his arguments in the case, Zafar said that the petitions against the 21st Amendment were dismissed by a ratio of 13:4 in a full court.

However, many judges gave different reasons for dismissing the petitions, he added.

Zafar told the court that the constitution mentions that the parliamentary party will give directions to the lawmakers about voting.

At this, the CJP questioned whether the party head and parliamentary party were two separate entities.

Zafar said that they were two separate entities.

CJP Bandial said that the parliamentary party does not may its decision on its own. In light of the political party’s directions, the parliamentary party makes its decision. 

Justice Ahsan then said, according to the constitution, the party head follows the parliamentary party’s directions. The CJP said that the parliamentary party does not make a decision unilaterally.

“The parliamentary party is informed about the party’s decision, and based on that, it takes a decision.”

During the proceedings, Justice Ahsan questioned: “Where has the word parliamentary leader been used?”

The PML-Q counsel replied that the world “parliamentary party” is used in the Political Parties Order 2002.

At this, Justice Ahsan remarked that the word “parliamentary leader” instead of “parliamentary party” is just a mistake.

Additional Attorney-General (AAG) Amir Rehman then came to the rostrum and said he wanted to present a few suggestions before the court.

“Has the federal government decided to separate itself from the coalition government?” the CJP asked.

The AAG told the top judge that he will assist the court under Article 27.

At this, the CJP extended an open invitation to assist the court to reach a fair and just decision in the high-profile case.

The court then went on a break for an hour and said that the hearing will resume at 2:30pm.

Parliamentary party gives directions for voting: CJP

After the hearing resumed, the former advocate-general of Punjab, Ahmed Owais, came to the rostrum.

“I want to inform the Supreme Court of a few things. For three months, the matter of the chief minister is under discussion. Let me tell the court that Q-league members were aware whom they had to vote for,” Owais said.

He urged the court to review the events that took place not only during the election but also before it.

Moving on, Zafar, while referring to the verdict in former PTI lawmaker Ayesha Gulalai’s case, said that the court had set the procedure for the directions of the party head.

At this, Justice Ahsan remarked that the court, in that case, had delivered its verdict against Zafar’s client.

The lawyer said that the verdict, in that case, was against his client but in accordance with the Constitution.

“Is it written in the Ayesha Gulalai case that who will give directions?” asked the CJP.

It is declared in the case that the party head or a person nominated by them can file a disqualification reference, replied the lawyer.

The CJP then said that the authority is transferred through the party head and there is no doubt that the head’s office plays an important role, but at the same time, the parliamentary party gives directions for voting.

‘Not compulsory to comply with each verdict of SC’

Justice Munib remarked that empowering the parliamentary party is tantamount to strengthening democracy. Reffering to Article 63-A of the Constitution, the apex court judge said it is necessary to give powers to the parliamentary party.

At this, the additional attorney general said that according to a Supreme Court’s 2015 decision, the party head can give direction and it is compulsory for the lawmakers of the party to comply with the direction until the top court reviews its verdict.

“It is not compulsory to comply with each verdict of the SC,” remarked Justice Munib.

“There are rulings that the SC’s decisions are binding on all other courts,” replied the attorney general.

The judge asked if it is necessary for the deputy speaker to comply with the ECP’s decision. The attorney general replied, “No, it is not necessary.”

The judge remarked that the deputy speaker should have written if the verdict in the 21st amendment was in his mind.

At this, the chief justice thanked all the lawyers and said that the SC wanted to strengthen the constitution.

Tags: Chief Justice of PakistanCJPCM PunjabSupreme Court of Pakistan
ShareTweetShareSend
Previous Post

Tech giants to self-regulate in reducing harmful content in New Zealand

Next Post

‘Not such a bad idea’ to appoint next army chief beforehand: President Arif Alvi

Arshad Khan

Arshad Khan

Related Posts

E-Procurement: Over 28,000 Local, International Firms Register on PPRA Platform

E-Procurement: Over 28,000 Local, International Firms Register on PPRA Platform

by Arshad Khan
May 14, 2025
0

The Pakistan Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA) is an autonomous regulatory body formed under the PPRA Ordinance E-Procurement: Over 28,000...

1965 War: 60 Years On, Pakistan's Unity & Spirit Remain Unshakable

1965 War: 60 Years On, Pakistan’s Unity & Spirit Remain Unshakable

by Arshad Khan
May 14, 2025
0

Pakistan’s Resilient Response Rekindles Spirit of 1965 Amid Renewed Tensions with India Tensions between Pakistan and India have a long...

Imran Khan's Sons Break Silence on Father's Jail Ordeal

Imran Khan’s Sons Break Silence on Father’s Jail Ordeal

by Arshad Khan
May 14, 2025
0

Khan’s son Suleman and Qasim Khan, who remained in shadows, appeared in first interview and revealed ordeal of their father....

EWCA Islamabad Elects New Leadership to Energize Alumni Network

EWCA Islamabad Elects New Leadership to Energize Alumni Network

by Arshad Khan
May 13, 2025
0

The elections were held at the house of former Vice President Usman Rafique. EWCA Islamabad Elects New Leadership to Energize...

New Parking Rule Introduced for Vehicles in Islamabad

New Parking Rule Introduced for Vehicles in Islamabad

by Arshad Khan
May 13, 2025
0

Residents and business owners are advised to follow the new rules to avoid fines. New Parking Rule Introduced for Vehicles...

Pakistan Launches Initiative to Plant Fruit Trees Along Highways, Motorways

Pakistan Launches Initiative to Plant Fruit Trees Along Highways, Motorways

by Arshad Khan
May 13, 2025
0

Stressing the importance of public-private partnerships in achieving Pakistan’s environmental goals, Dr. Musadik Malik said Pakistan Launches Initiative to Plant...

40 Pakistani Civilians, 11 Soldiers Martyred in Indian Aggression, Pak Army Confirms

40 Pakistani Civilians, 11 Soldiers Martyred in Indian Aggression, Pak Army Confirms

by Arshad Khan
May 13, 2025
0

India Targeted Civilians in Attack, Says ISPR; Women and Children Among Martyrs 40 Pakistani Civilians, 11 Soldiers Martyred in Indian...

Load More
Next Post
'Not such a bad idea' to appoint next army chief beforehand: President Arif Alvi

'Not such a bad idea' to appoint next army chief beforehand: President Arif Alvi

Bangladesh seeks IMF support

Bangladesh seeks IMF support

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Twitter Youtube Instagram LinkedIn
FactFile

Newsletter

Subscribe to receive regular updates from FactFile.
SUBSCRIBE

Categories

  • Business
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • FactFile
  • Fashion
  • Health
  • International
  • Interview
  • Lifestyle
  • National
  • Opinion
  • People
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Tech

Site Links

  • About Us
  • Our Contributors
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

© 2020-25 Daily FactFile

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Science
  • National
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Fashion
  • Lifestyle
  • Tech
  • Health

© 2020-25 Daily FactFile